Idealism vs. Realism

Posted on 09.03.06 in Faith and there are 20 comments.

Where do you draw the line between idealism and realism?

Lately we’ve had several discussions here about marketing. There was the discussion about Leigh Nash and Automated friendship and then more recently we’ve been talking about the (not quite) Free Derek Webb promotion. Now Shaun Groves has confessed (he calls it a confession) to using a program to automate his MySpace friend requests and comments.

I’ve been trying to figure out what I think about all this. I know it all seems trivial and you’re probably thinking, “What’s the big deal, Kat?”

Well, I don’t know. That’s what I’m trying to figure out.

I just don’t think any of these marketing methods are ideal. Effective....yes. Ideal....no.

Ideally, I think that we as Christians should seek to be above reproach in all we do. We should seek to be sincere and truthful in every aspect of who we are. We should take the high road and steer clear of the grey areas or questionable actions.

But what happens when insincerity is acceptable to our audience? What happens when slight manipulations or deceits are common practice? What happens when no one cares if we step into the grey areas?

Now, please don’t think that I’m just railing on these three artists. I’m not. Granted these discussions have been a catalyst for this post, but before you think I’m throwing stones I have a few facts for you to read:
1. I’ve been known to sneak snacks into the movie theater.
2. I often drive 3-5 miles over the speed limit.
3. My real name isn’t Kat.

Realistically, not many people care about Myspace programs or submitting email addresses to get a cd.

Realistically, both of those marketing promotions have drastically increased the exposure of artists whose desire it is to lead people to Jesus.

Realistically, no one really cares (except maybe me...)

So where do we go from here? Where do we draw the line between idealism and realism? Do you think the grey areas are acceptable...or even actually grey?

Is what we’re doing fine? If not, how do we stick to our ideals and still get our message out?

My Twitter Posts